Data di Pubblicazione:
2018
Citazione:
What anti-realism about hinges could possibly be? / Coliva, A.. - (2018), pp. 267-288. [10.1007/978-3-319-93369-6_12]
Abstract:
The paper addresses the issue of what epistemic anti-realism could possibly be, in the context of “hinge epistemology.” According to this new epistemological trend, justification depends on evidence together with
general background assumptions—for example, that there is an external world, that our sense organs are
mostly reliable, that we are not the victims of persistent and lucid dreams what has regularly happened in
the past will happen in the future, that people are generally reliable informants, and so on. The paper then
addresses two issues. First, whether these assumptions are arbitrary, as relativists would claim. Second,
how we should conceive of their metaphysical status. It responds negatively to the first question and puts
forward an anti-realist conception of hinges to respond to the latter. Central to the proposal is that the kind
of truth that can be predicated of hinges is of a minimalist kind. The paper also explores the compatibility
of minimalism about hinges' truth and alethic pluralism .
general background assumptions—for example, that there is an external world, that our sense organs are
mostly reliable, that we are not the victims of persistent and lucid dreams what has regularly happened in
the past will happen in the future, that people are generally reliable informants, and so on. The paper then
addresses two issues. First, whether these assumptions are arbitrary, as relativists would claim. Second,
how we should conceive of their metaphysical status. It responds negatively to the first question and puts
forward an anti-realist conception of hinges to respond to the latter. Central to the proposal is that the kind
of truth that can be predicated of hinges is of a minimalist kind. The paper also explores the compatibility
of minimalism about hinges' truth and alethic pluralism .
Tipologia CRIS:
Capitolo/Saggio
Keywords:
Hinge epistemology, relativism, anti-realism, alethic pluralism
Elenco autori:
Coliva, A.
Link alla scheda completa:
Link al Full Text:
Titolo del libro:
Epistemological Realism and Anti-Realism: Approaches to Metaepistemology